Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia Reinstates $9.86 Million Judgment on Behalf of Client Mike Rodgers
On November 12, 2026, in a long-awaited victory on behalf of our client Michael Rodgers, the Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia reinstated a $9,862,384.58 medical malpractice judgment awarded in his favor in 2022.
Mr. Rodgers originally sustained injuries to his spinal column in a motorcycle accident and went to the Charleston Area Medical Center ("CAMC") where he was seen by a neurosurgeon, Dr. John R. Orphanos. Instead of properly testing Mr. Rodgers before surgery and using appropriate safety equipment during surgery, the doctor recklessly and negligently operated on Mr. Rodgers’ sensitive spinal column. When Mr. Rodgers emerged from surgery, he was rendered a paraplegic and is now wheelchair-bound for the rest of his life.
In 2022, we originally secured a $17 million jury verdict on behalf of Mr. Rodgers. The original trial team comprised of Bailey Glasser partners Greg Haddad, Kerrie Lynne Haddad, and Sharon F. Iskra tried the case over eight days in Charleston, West Virginia state court, in a matter that was heavily fought by the defendant who sought to avoid responsibility for his negligence. The amount was subsequently reduced by the trial court to $9,862,384.58.
In addition to the original Bailey Glasser trial team, the appeal was argued by Of Counsel John W. Barrett. To read the opinion by the Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia, please visit this link. To watch Mr. Barrett's oral argument before the Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia, visit here.
After we won the jury verdict, the doctor appealed. In a resounding victory for justice, the Supreme Court rejected the defense arguments and has awarded Mr. Rodgers the financial compensation to which he is entitled and that will make a huge difference in the quality of his life.
Lead trial counsel Greg Haddad commented: “The Supreme Court decision upholds the important precedent that when medical professionals provide substandard care to their patients, then they can expect to be held to account for their carelessness.” He added: “We are grateful that the Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia has reinstated the jury verdict that will take care of Mr. Rodgers and provide the services he will need. Although his health will never be restored, this ruling, on top of the original jury verdict, sends a message to doctors and institutions who try to take shortcuts with patients and by doing so, play with their lives.”
In addition to our lawyers, we are grateful for the dedicated work done by Bailey Glasser paralegals Farrah Caruthers and Kim Walker.
Case Background
In June 2017, Mr. Rodgers was flown to Charleston Area Medical Center, a Level I trauma center, after a motorcycle accident. Scans showed a fracture of his fifth thoracic vertebra. The next day, Dr. John R. Orphanos presented two options: wear a back brace, or undergo surgery to place hardware in the spine. Mr. Rodgers consented to surgery. Before the operation, he had full sensation and strength in all four limbs. When he woke, he had no movement or feeling below his chest. The paralysis was permanent.
Mr. Rodgers filed suit in 2019. He alleged that Dr. Orphanos breached the standard of care by failing to order a preoperative MRI, failing to use spinal cord monitoring during surgery, and failing to order a CT myelogram before a second, exploratory surgery. In 2020, while the case was pending, Mr. Rodgers suffered a stroke.
After a seven-day trial in March 2022, a Kanawha County jury found Dr. Orphanos negligent. It found that his negligence caused both the paralysis and the later stroke, and it awarded $17,770,875. After reductions required by statute, the circuit court entered judgment of $9,862,384.58.
In 2024, the Intermediate Court of Appeals upheld most of the trial court's rulings but ordered a new trial on damages. It found that the trial court should have allowed a defense expert's late-disclosed opinion on Mr. Rodgers's life expectancy.
Both sides then appealed to the Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia.
In a lengthy opinion, the Supreme Court decided that the West Virginia trauma cap did not apply in this instance. West Virginia law limits damages to $500,000 per occurrence for injuries arising from emergency care at a designated trauma center. When the care at issue is surgery performed after the patient's condition has stabilized, the cap applies only if the surgery was required by the emergency condition and performed within a reasonable time. The Court held that the defendant seeking the cap must invoke it and prove each of these facts. Dr. Orphanos had testified that Mr. Rodgers was clinically stable and that no emergency required rushing him to the operating room. He offered no evidence or jury instructions to show the surgery was required or timely. The cap therefore did not apply.
The Court also, among other rulings, determined that the defendant was not entitled to a new trial.
Related Materials
Practice Areas
- Appellate & Supreme Court Practice
- Catastrophic Personal Injury
- Hospital Malpractice
- Institutional Abuse & Neglect
- Legionnaires' Disease
- Maryland Juvenile Hall Sexual Abuse
- Medical Device & Drugs
- Medical Malpractice
- Personal Injury & Product Liability
- Traumatic Brain Injuries
- Veterans Medical Malpractice